Avoiding the Nightmare Before Christmas
It was the night before the staff Christmas party, and all through the office, not a creature was stirring, except perhaps the manager drafting the annual reminder about acceptable behaviour at work functions. Because, as every employer knows, what begins as a festive celebration can all too easily turn into the nightmare before Christmas.
Maybe you have heard the stories, or perhaps even lived them.
There is the employee who decides that three glasses of champagne make them suitably qualified to give the CEO some unsolicited feedback about their leadership style. The manager whose dance moves become the talk of the office for all the wrong reasons. Or the colleague who mistakes a little festive friendliness for an invitation to pursue a romantic interest that is clearly not reciprocated.
And then there is always the employee who wakes up on Saturday morning, checks the work group chat and discovers that their finest moments from the night before have already been shared with the entire team.
Funny? Perhaps. An HR disaster waiting to happen? Absolutely.
While some Christmas party antics might provide office gossip for weeks to come, others can have far more serious consequences. What starts as a few drinks and a bit of festive fun can quickly escalate into allegations of misconduct, sexual harassment, disciplinary action and, in some cases, costly legal proceedings.
And with Christmas party season fast approaching, employers would be wise to remember that the usual standards of workplace behaviour do not simply disappear when the drinks start flowing.
Can employers be held responsible for what happens at a Christmas party?
The short answer is yes, depending on the circumstances.
A Christmas party organised or sponsored by an employer will generally be considered a work-related event. This means employees are still expected to comply with appropriate standards of behaviour, even if the celebration takes place outside normal working hours.
Sexual harassment, bullying, discrimination, aggression and other inappropriate behaviour can have serious consequences for both employees and employers.
Under the Sex Discrimination Act 1984 (Cth), employers also have a positive duty to take reasonable and proportionate measures to eliminate, as far as possible, certain unlawful conduct, including workplace sexual harassment and sex-based harassment.
That responsibility extends to work-related social functions.
Employers may also be held legally liable for certain conduct by employees unless they can establish the relevant statutory defence, including having taken all reasonable steps to prevent the conduct.
In other words, simply having a workplace policy sitting in a folder somewhere is unlikely to be enough.
When the Christmas party ends, does the employer's responsibility end too?
Not necessarily, and this is where things can become particularly complicated.
In Keenan v Leighton Boral Amey NSW Pty Ltd [2015] FWC 3156, an employee attended a work Christmas function and engaged in inappropriate behaviour, including offensive comments towards colleagues and senior employees. Following the official function, the celebrations continued elsewhere, with further allegations arising from the employee's conduct.
The employee was subsequently dismissed, but the Fair Work Commission found the dismissal unfair, with one of the important issues considered was whether the conduct occurring after the official function had ended was sufficiently connected to employment to justify disciplinary action.
Fast-forward 10 years, and the FWC takes a different view in Cameron Bell v Arts Centre Melbourne [2026] FWC 3212. After the employer’s December 2024 Christmas function, employees continued drinking at a nearby bar. A confrontation ended with a building maintenance officer punching a colleague in the head, causing him to fall into a heater and then onto the ground.
The Commission upheld the dismissal. It rejected self-defence and found sufficient connection with employment, notwithstanding that the employer had not organised the later gathering. A proper investigation and opportunity to respond also supported the employer’s position.
The lesson for employers is that inappropriate behaviour at a Christmas party may justify disciplinary action, including dismissal, but the circumstances matter.
Employers need to establish what actually occurred, whether the conduct was sufficiently connected to employment and whether the proposed disciplinary response is appropriate.
And importantly, even where an employee's conduct is unacceptable, employers must still follow a fair process.
Alcohol is not an excuse for bad behaviour
It is not uncommon for employers to provide alcohol at Christmas celebrations. However, supplying alcohol without appropriate controls can create additional risks.
Employees remain responsible for their behaviour, regardless of whether they have been drinking.
Equally, employers need to consider how alcohol is being managed at an event they have organised or funded.
Providing unlimited alcohol, failing to intervene when someone becomes visibly intoxicated or allowing inappropriate behaviour to continue unchecked may create difficulties if an incident subsequently occurs.
This does not mean employers need to ban alcohol from Christmas parties. However, responsible service, appropriate supervision and clear behavioural expectations should be part of the planning.
After all, nobody wants to spend the Monday morning after the Christmas party interviewing witnesses about what happened on the dance floor.
What if someone makes a complaint?
Imagine receiving a call on Monday morning from an employee alleging that a colleague sexually harassed them at Friday night's Christmas party.
The fact that the incident occurred at a social function does not mean the employer can dismiss it as something that happened outside work.
Employers should take complaints seriously, assess the circumstances and determine the appropriate response.
Depending on the allegations, this may involve a formal and independent workplace investigation, interviews with witnesses, consideration of available evidence and disciplinary action where warranted.
Employers also need to ensure that employees involved in the process are treated fairly and that appropriate confidentiality is maintained.
One of the biggest mistakes an employer can make is assuming that because everyone had been drinking, the matter should simply be forgotten.
It should not.
How can employers avoid the nightmare?
Fortunately, preventing Christmas party problems does not require cancelling the celebrations or turning the event into another workplace training session.
A few sensible precautions can make a significant difference.
Before the event, remind employees that workplace behavioural standards continue to apply. Make sure relevant policies are up to date and that employees know how to raise concerns.
Consider how alcohol will be managed, whether the venue and planned activities are appropriate, and whether managers understand their responsibilities if behaviour becomes concerning.
It is also worth considering transport arrangements and making it clear when the official function concludes.
Most importantly, managers need to lead by example. It is difficult to enforce appropriate standards of behaviour when the people responsible for managing the event are contributing to the problem.
Make it a Christmas party to remember, for the right reasons.
Christmas parties are an opportunity to recognise employees, celebrate achievements and enjoy time together away from the usual demands of work.
They should be enjoyable, and nobody is suggesting that employers need to remove the fun.
However, a little preparation can prevent a great night from becoming a very expensive workplace problem.
So, before the bubbles start flowing and someone shouts for one more round, take a moment to consider whether your business has done what it reasonably can to manage the risks.
To help you prepare, we have put together a free eBook with practical guidance for employers on managing workplace Christmas celebrations. Download your free Christmas party eBook.
And remember, if something does go wrong, do not ignore it simply because it happened at the Christmas party.
If your business needs assistance reviewing workplace policies, managing employee misconduct or investigating a complaint arising from a work-related function, contact Effective Workplace Solutions on (02) 6676 3445 or email enquiries@ewsolutions.com.au.
Disclaimer: This article is general in nature and provides a summary only of the subject matter without the assumption of a duty of care by Effective Workplace Solutions. No person should rely on the contents as a substitute for legal or other professional advice.

